The integrability obstruction of the conformal flattening equation #
In dimension at least 3, a metric e^(2φ) g has vanishing Schouten tensor exactly when φ
solves the conformal flattening equation
Hess φ = P + dφ ⊗ dφ - (|dφ|² / 2) g,
where P is the Schouten tensor of g
(Bundle.ContMDiffRiemannianMetric.schoutenTensor_leviCivitaConnection_rescale_eq_zero_iff).
This is a first-order system for the gradient ξ = grad φ: its right side
Φ_ξ(u, v) = P(u, v) + ⟪ξ, u⟫ ⟪ξ, v⟫ - (‖ξ‖² / 2) ⟪u, v⟫ depends only on the point and the value
of ξ there (CovariantDerivative.conformalFlatteningForm). Differentiating Φ_ξ along a
solution, and substituting the equation for the derivative of ξ, gives the trilinear form
D_ξ(u, v, w) = (∇_w P)(u, v) + Φ_ξ(w, u) ⟪ξ, v⟫ + ⟪ξ, u⟫ Φ_ξ(w, v) - Φ_ξ(w, ξ) ⟪u, v⟫
(CovariantDerivative.conformalFlatteningDeriv), again a function of the point and of ξ alone.
For a solution φ, D_(grad φ) is the covariant derivative of Hess φ
(TauCeti.Manifold.mvfderiv_hessian_sub_eq_conformalFlatteningDeriv).
The Ricci identity says that (∇_w Hess φ)(u, v) - (∇_v Hess φ)(u, w) = ⟪R(w, v) grad φ, u⟫, so the
system can only be solved with prescribed value ξ at a point where
D_ξ(u, v, w) - D_ξ(u, w, v) = ⟪R(w, v) ξ, u⟫. The main computation of this file identifies the
defect in this identity for every vector ξ, solution or not:
D_ξ(u, v, w) - D_ξ(u, w, v) - ⟪R(w, v) ξ, u⟫ = C(u, v, w) + W(w, v, u, ξ),
with C the Cotton tensor and W the Weyl tensor
(CovariantDerivative.IsMetricCompatible.conformalFlatteningDeriv_sub_swap). All terms quadratic
and cubic in ξ cancel, and the terms linear in ξ assemble into P ⊙ g, which turns the
curvature term into the Weyl tensor. Consequently the obstruction vanishes for every ξ at a point
where W = 0 and C = 0; conversely, if the system has a solution through every value ξ at x,
then C = 0 and W = 0 at x. The first statement is the involutivity condition in the proof that
vanishing Weyl tensor (dimension at least 4) or vanishing Cotton tensor (dimension 3) implies
local conformal flatness.
The same computation applies to an arbitrary smooth φ that solves the equation only at the single
point x: writing ψ = Hess φ - Φ_(grad φ) for the defect of the equation, the derivatives of ψ
at x satisfy Z (ψ(X, Y)) - Y (ψ(X, Z)) = -(C(X, Y, Z) + W(Z, Y, X, grad φ))
(TauCeti.Manifold.mvfderiv_hessian_sub_conformalFlatteningForm_sub_swap). This is the form in
which the Frobenius integrability condition of the equation is verified.
Main declarations #
CovariantDerivative.conformalFlatteningForm: the right sideΦ_ξof the conformal flattening equation.CovariantDerivative.conformalFlatteningDeriv: its derivativeD_ξalong a solution.CovariantDerivative.IsMetricCompatible.conformalFlatteningDeriv_sub_swap:D_ξ(u, v, w) - D_ξ(u, w, v) = ⟪R(w, v) ξ, u⟫ + C(u, v, w) + W(w, v, u, ξ).TauCeti.Manifold.mvfderiv_conformalFlatteningForm_sub_eq_conformalFlatteningDeriv: whereHess φ = Φ_(grad φ)atx, the covariant derivative ofΦ_(grad φ)atxisD_(grad φ x).TauCeti.Manifold.mvfderiv_hessian_sub_conformalFlatteningForm_sub_swap: the antisymmetrized derivative of the defectHess φ - Φ_(grad φ)at a point where it vanishes is-(C + W).TauCeti.Manifold.cottonTensor_add_weylTensor_eq_zero_of_eventually_hessian_eq: along a solutionφ,C(u, v, w) + W(w, v, u, grad φ) = 0.TauCeti.Manifold.cottonTensor_eq_zero_of_eventually_hessian_eqandTauCeti.Manifold.weylTensor_eq_zero_of_forall_exists_eventually_hessian_eq: solutions through every value of the gradient at a point forceC = 0andW = 0there.
References #
- J. M. Lee and T. H. Parker, The Yamabe problem, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 17 (1987), Section 2.
- A. L. Besse, Einstein Manifolds, Springer (1987), Section 1.G (the Weyl–Schouten theorem).
The right side of the conformal flattening equation Hess φ = Φ_(grad φ),
Φ_ξ(u, v) = P(u, v) + ⟪ξ, u⟫ ⟪ξ, v⟫ - (‖ξ‖² / 2) ⟪u, v⟫, where P is the Schouten tensor.
Instances For
Evaluation of the right side of the conformal flattening equation.
The derivative of the right side Φ_ξ of the conformal flattening equation along a solution,
D_ξ(u, v, w) = (∇_w P)(u, v) + Φ_ξ(w, u) ⟪ξ, v⟫ + ⟪ξ, u⟫ Φ_ξ(w, v) - Φ_ξ(w, ξ) ⟪u, v⟫, with the
derivative direction w last as in CovariantDerivative.derivSchoutenTensor.
Instances For
Evaluation of the derivative of the right side of the conformal flattening equation.
For a metric-compatible torsion-free connection, the right side of the conformal flattening equation is symmetric.
The integrability obstruction of the conformal flattening equation. For a
metric-compatible torsion-free connection and every tangent vector ξ,
D_ξ(u, v, w) - D_ξ(u, w, v) = ⟪R(w, v) ξ, u⟫ + (C(u, v, w) + W(w, v, u, ξ)), where D_ξ is
CovariantDerivative.conformalFlatteningDeriv, C the Cotton tensor and W the Weyl tensor.
Along a solution of the equation the Ricci identity gives
D_ξ(u, v, w) - D_ξ(u, w, v) = ⟪R(w, v) ξ, u⟫, so C(u, v, w) + W(w, v, u, ξ) must vanish at x
for the equation to have a solution near x with gradient ξ at x.
At a point where the Weyl and Cotton tensors vanish, the integrability obstruction of the
conformal flattening equation vanishes for every value ξ:
D_ξ(u, v, w) - D_ξ(u, w, v) = ⟪R(w, v) ξ, u⟫.
The conformal flattening equation. In dimension at least 3, the metric f g with
f = e^(2φ) has vanishing Schouten tensor at x exactly when
Hess φ = P + dφ ⊗ dφ - (|dφ|² / 2) g at x, where the Hessian, the gradient and the Schouten
tensor P are those of g.
If the Hessian of φ at x is the right side Φ_(grad φ x) of the conformal flattening
equation, then the covariant derivative at x of the field of bilinear forms
y ↦ Φ_(grad φ y) is D_(grad φ x):
(∇_w Φ_(grad φ))(X, Y) = D_(grad φ x)(X, Y, w), where
(∇_w Φ_(grad φ))(X, Y) = w (Φ_(grad φ)(X, Y)) - Φ_(grad φ)(∇_w X, Y) - Φ_(grad φ)(X, ∇_w Y) and
D is CovariantDerivative.conformalFlatteningDeriv for the Levi-Civita connection. Only the
equation at the single point x is used: it replaces the Hessian of φ, which appears in the
derivative of grad φ, by Φ_(grad φ x).
Along a solution φ of the conformal flattening equation Hess φ = Φ_(grad φ) near x, the
covariant derivative of the Hessian is D_(grad φ):
(∇_w Hess φ)(X, Y) = D_(grad φ)(X, Y, w), where
(∇_w Hess φ)(X, Y) = w (Hess φ(X, Y)) - Hess φ(∇_w X, Y) - Hess φ(X, ∇_w Y) and D is
CovariantDerivative.conformalFlatteningDeriv for the Levi-Civita connection.
The integrability defect of the conformal flattening equation along a function. Let φ be
smooth, with Hess φ = Φ_(grad φ) at the single point x, and write
ψ(X, Y) = Hess φ(X, Y) - Φ_(grad φ)(X, Y) for the defect of the equation. For smooth vector fields
X, Y, Z, the derivatives of ψ at x satisfy
Z (ψ(X, Y)) - Y (ψ(X, Z)) = -(C(X, Y, Z) + W(Z, Y, X, grad φ)), with C the Cotton tensor and
W the Weyl tensor of the Levi-Civita connection. Thus where C and W vanish, the first
derivatives at x of the defect are symmetric in this sense: this is the Frobenius integrability
condition of the equation, written invariantly.
The integrability condition of the conformal flattening equation. If a smooth φ solves
Hess φ = P + dφ ⊗ dφ - (|dφ|² / 2) g near x, then the Cotton and Weyl tensors of the
Levi-Civita connection satisfy C(u, v, w) + W(w, v, u, grad φ) = 0 at x.
If the conformal flattening equation has a smooth solution near x whose gradient vanishes at
x, then the Cotton tensor of the Levi-Civita connection vanishes at x.
If the conformal flattening equation has a smooth solution near x through every value
grad φ x = ξ of the gradient at x, then the Weyl tensor of the Levi-Civita connection vanishes
at x.